Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (2024)

I look forward to cherry season all year. Here are our favorite, most tried and true sour cherry recipes of all time. You can make almost all of them with freshly picked, frozen, or jarred Morello or Montmorency cherries.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (1)

What to do with sour cherries, like,right now

(Editor's note: This introductory text is from the post's original publication date in June, 2016.)

Earlier this week we spent a fantastic morning with friends picking sour cherries atBattleview Orchardsin Freehold, NJ. Their sour cherry trees are lovely, petite little creatures just perfect for kids to get all up in.

While I was picking in a leisurely fashion, chatting with my friend Rachel, the kids collected 13 pounds of fruit in under 45 minutes. As all fans of pick your own will know, the limiting factor in these expeditions is not the picking itself but the processing at home afterwards, which can be time consuming and, in the case of cherries, a little messy.

I’m lucky to have a small, cute team of eager (and these days very capable) cooks and bakers on hand to help. Still, 13 pounds. Blogger that I am, before we’d even left the farm my brain was forming a question that doubles as a post title: What to Do with Sour Cherries (?!?!).

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (2)

What are they?

Sour cherries, also called tart cherries, are delicate, thin-skinned, and bright red. As the name suggests, they're very sour, and they have a floral briskness that really shines when lightly sweetened. They come in several varieties, including Moreno andMontmorency(pictured). You can use them interchangeably.

How to process them

Tart cherries are delicate, so if you're picking them nice and ripe, it's important to process them right away. (They're more like berries than other cherries in this regard.) You can keep whole or pitted cherries in the fridge for a day or two. Any longer and it's best to freeze them.

I've always found that a good old cherry pitter works very well, but some people prefer to use a small paper clip to remove the pits.

Regardless of the tool you choose, I highly recommend recruiting some help. Nearly anyone can participate, and it's a great excuse to slow down, sit around, and chat.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (3)

I like to set up three rimmed sheet pans next to each other on the kitchen floor and have pitters sit on either side.

  • Place the whole cherries on one pan
  • Use the middle pan to catch pits and stems. (Remove each stem before pitting.)
  • Place pitted cherries on the remaining pan.

Then we triage the cherries, reserving enough fresh ones for the recipes we want to make right away, and freezing the rest to use later in the year.

How to freeze them

Here's how to freeze sour cherries:

  • Rinse and dry those sheet pans (or use smaller rimmed pans if necessary to fit in your freezer).
  • Line with parchment
  • Arrange cherries in a single layer on each pan. It's okay if they're snug, but try not to overlap them.
  • Place in the freezer until they're frozen solid.
  • After that, you can transfer them into zip-top freezer bags or reusable airtight containers. They'll keep really well for the whole year, until it's time to pick again.
Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (4)

Our favorite recipes using sour cherries

Here are some of our favorite ways to use sour cherries:

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (5)

Sour cherry cake is a beautiful seasonal adaptation of my all-time favoriteNorwegian Gold cake. The tart cherries really shine in this rich golden dessert perfumed with vanilla and almond.

Sour cherry frozen yogurt is bright, refreshing, and bursting with flavor. It's a great way to enjoy sour cherries at the height of summer — but since it's made with frozen fruit, you can go for it anytime.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (7)

Sour cherry crisp is an easy and beautiful way to let this fleeting seasonal ingredient shine, without overwhelming it. Make-ahead friendly and ready in an hour.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (8)

Sour cherry muffins combine the twin summer joys of tart cherries and corn. They're based on our favoritebuttermilk cornbread muffins, which have just the right balance of light sweetness and gentle heft. The cherries are an absolutely natural fit.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (9)

The classic French 75 uses fresh lemon juice and simple syrup to create a smooth, sour sparkling gin drink. In this sour cherry co*cktail, we brighten things up withhomemade cherry syrupfor a blush-colored seasonal twist.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (10)

Here's how to make homemade maraschino cherries two ways: a kid-friendly version for Shirleys and desserts and a boozy, adults-only version for co*cktails.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (11)

Use this easy, versatile sour cherry syrup in aco*cktail, aShirley Temple, or drizzled liberally into soda water to make an Italian soda. It's ready in minutes and keeps for a month in the fridge.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (12)

Our Shirley Temple recipe is a big hit with the littles. You can use ourhomemade sour cherry syrupor bottled grenadine, and make other customizations to suit your tastes. Here's how to do it.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (13)

And don't miss Domenica Marchetti’srecipe for sour cherry pie(via NPR).

That's it for our favorite sour cherry recipes. Feel free to leave any questions in the comments section. xx

Hungry for more?

Subscribe to Umami Girl's email updates, and follow along on Instagram.

Sour Cherry Recipes: Our All-Time Favorites - Umami Girl (2024)

FAQs

What is one of the most popular sour cherries? ›

Montmorency Cherries

These red cherries are the most popular sour variety, which doesn't mean they're never enjoyed as a snack, but they are more often cooked, dried, canned, or frozen. They're also squeezed for their juice and used in pie filling, jams, and preserves.

What is the difference between sour cherries and tart cherries? ›

Tart cherries (scientific name Prunus cerasus) are also called sour cherries. They are best known as a key ingredient in desserts; most importantly, the cherry pie. However, tart cherries are also delicious in preserves, main courses, salads, side dishes and beverages.

How do you eat sour cherries? ›

And unlike other cherries, which can be eaten out of hand, sour cherries are best when cooked and sweetened. Using sour cherries is simpler than you might think—they are delicious in drinks, soups, entrées, and desserts for a sweet and tangy surprise.

What is the difference between sweet cherry and sour cherry trees? ›

Unlike sweet cherries, one of the most important differences with sour cherries is that most are self-pollinating – you only need one tree to harvest a full crop. The trees are also naturally smaller, so they fit into smaller gardens so easily.

What is a sour cherry called in English? ›

Prunus cerasus (sour cherry, tart cherry, or dwarf cherry) is a species of Prunus in the subgenus Cerasus (cherries), native to much of Europe, North Africa and West Asia. It is closely related to the sweet cherry (Prunus avium), but has a fruit that is more acidic. Its sour pulp is edible.

Are sour cherries healthier? ›

Super Fruit Health Benefits of Sour - or Tart - Cherries

In more recent studies, the term “super fruit” has become associated with the Sour Cherry. This is due to the high antioxidant values the Sour Cherry possesses.

Why are sour cherries so expensive? ›

Also, Cherries simply come and go quite quickly, so it is rare to find cherries on sale or offered at a low price. The reason cherries are so expensive is because fungicides are required to keep the fruits in good shape and not lose them completely.

What are the best sour cherries? ›

Grown in Michigan, Montmorency cherries are the most popular sour cherries in the U.S. You can typically find them frozen or canned, rather than fresh. Classic sour cherry pies are typically made with this variety. They're also used to make tart cherry juice.

Are sour cherries healthier than sweet cherries? ›

Sweet cherries have better anti-inflammatory properties than their tart counterparts. They contain more considerable amounts of anthocyanin phytonutrients, a compound that gives cherries their signature red hue. This compound has been linked to reduced risks for heart disease, plaque formation, and cancer.

What are the little white worms in sour cherries? ›

Numerous gardeners have complained about finding the little white worms in cherries just at harvest time. These worms are the larvae of a fruit fly that has been a pest in Japan for decades but somehow made it to the US. It has no known enemies in the US, so it has spread, unchecked, like wildfire.

What does sour cherry do for the body? ›

Sour cherry is used for osteoarthritis, muscle pain, exercise-related muscle damage, gout, insomnia, to increase urine production, and to help digestion. In foods, sour cherries are eaten as a food or flavoring. In manufacturing, sour cherry is used to make cherry syrup for drugs with an unpleasant taste.

How many sour cherries should you eat a day? ›

You'll reap cherry benefits regardless of whether you like your stone fruit sweet or sour. Sweet cherries may be more delightful for your tastebuds when you eat them by the handful. Tart cherries are often used in baking. “Aim for one cup of fresh cherries a day or a quarter-cup of dried ones,” suggests Sedlacek.

What are the best sour cherries for baking? ›

Montmorency, Morello, and Balaton are all sour cherry varieties. They're usually soft, and smaller than sweet cherries. Some are sweet-tart, others are so sour your cheeks pucker. Use them to bake pie, crumbles, compotes, salsas, and to top yogurt.

Are Morello cherries the same as sour cherries? ›

Morello cherries refer to a family of sour cherries that have become popular for their use in pies and other baked goods. Like Montmorency cherries, Morello cherries are very tart and far too sour for most to enjoy raw.

What are the sweetest sour cherries? ›

Prunus cerasus 'Sweet Thing'

Sweet Thing really lives up to its name! Sweeter, firmer, and larger than most sour cherries, this variety is worth trying if you're a fan of Bing or BC cherries. Most sour cherries average 3-4 grams, whereas Sweet Thing produces cherries that average 5-6 grams.

What are the best tasting tart cherries? ›

Grown on small family farms in North America, Montmorency tart cherries are truly “The Cherry With More,” with their on-trend sweet-sour taste and unique nutrient profile. Montmorency tart cherries have been studied more than any other type of cherry – and the evidence is growing.

What are the most popular cherries? ›

Common Type of Cherries and their Uses
  • Bing Cherries. It's the most common type of sweet cherry you'll find in supermarkets, both fresh and frozen. ...
  • Black Cherries. ...
  • Rainier Cherries. ...
  • Chelan Cherries. ...
  • Montmorency Cherries. ...
  • English Morello Cherries. ...
  • Maraschino Cherries. ...
  • Amarena Cherries.
Aug 2, 2022

What is the sourest cherry? ›

Montmorency, Morello, and Balaton are all sour cherry varieties. They're usually soft, and smaller than sweet cherries. Some are sweet-tart, others are so sour your cheeks pucker. Use them to bake pie, crumbles, compotes, salsas, and to top yogurt.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Pres. Carey Rath

Last Updated:

Views: 5411

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Pres. Carey Rath

Birthday: 1997-03-06

Address: 14955 Ledner Trail, East Rodrickfort, NE 85127-8369

Phone: +18682428114917

Job: National Technology Representative

Hobby: Sand art, Drama, Web surfing, Cycling, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Leather crafting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Pres. Carey Rath, I am a faithful, funny, vast, joyous, lively, brave, glamorous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.